Butcher Bros Steakhouse

4.2
670 reviews

About

Steak House
Butcher Bros SteakHouse is a family owned & operated fine dining restaurant located in the heart of Cheshire, CT. Our menu features a wide variety of dishes - from the highest quality dry aged steak to bar bites - all made with the freshest local ingredients & prepared with care by our talented team - exclusively trained by Chef Dino Redzic. At Butcher Bros SteakHouse, we bring the NYC style fine dining experience to our quaint New England town. The Butcher Bros team can’t wait for you to join us - for a quick bite for happy hour, or a special occasion!

Location

Butcher Bros Steakhouse
1410 Highland Avenue, Cheshire, CT
06410, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.2
670 reviews
5 stars
460
4 stars
69
3 stars
44
2 stars
38
1 star
59

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

The food quality received mixed reviews, with some praising the steaks and seafood, while others found it overpriced and underwhelming.

Service

Service quality varied significantly; some customers reported excellent and attentive service, while others experienced long wait times and inattentive staff.

Pricing

Many customers felt the prices were too high for the quality of food and service received, leading to disappointment.

Atmosphere

The restaurant's ambiance was generally appreciated, though some noted it could use updates and improvements.

Consistency

There were inconsistencies in food preparation and service, with some diners having great experiences while others were left dissatisfied.
  • DV
    Daniel Varano
    1 day ago
    1.0
    8oz filet closer to 6 overcooked Tuff spinach not fresh Caesar salad flavorless , second dish sirloin overcooked 10oz tops tuff grizzly Very disappointing will not recommend Probably the worst prepared meal I’ve had
  • AG
    Allen Goldin
    Nov 15, 2025
    1.0
    Service was very slow, 25 minutes for a first drink, tomahawk steak was super fatty and bland (200$), first time here and not a great experience.
  • JC
    Jonathan Cappiello
    Nov 9, 2025
    5.0
    This place is a wonderful addition to the Cheshire community! They made our dining experience delightful and memorable. Edwin and his teams are extremely personable and made us feel like we are royalty — something to be marveled. The steak was cooked to perfection with impeccable sides. And most of all, they have a great birthday celebration tradition for their guests! Thanks again to the crew there — we will be back!!!
  • MM
    makenna m
    Nov 4, 2025
    1.0
    this calls for a LOCAL HEALTH department! my boyfriend and i went here for our first time for our anniversary. the atmosphere was inviting and had nice music playing. while entering, us and only one other couple were there. we ordered the meatballs to start, we were given fried mozzarella instead. NO WORRIES! those appetizers, were above exceptional. plus, the fried mozzarella was given to us on the house because of the mistake! my boyfriend ordered the filet migon with two sides. asparagus and truffle mac. i on the other hand, ordered fettuccine alfredo. we wish the steak was more tender. now, that isn't my problem. while we were eating, we saw this.
  • AB
    Amanda Bakutis
    Nov 1, 2025
    5.0
    It was our first time coming here. Everything was perfect. The service was phenomenal. Our waiter was so friendly & professional. The cocktails were so good. The appetizers & main course were delicious & cooked just how we asked. They even gave us a free dessert for our anniversary. We cannot wait to come back. Highly recommend!

Frequently Asked Questions About Butcher Bros Steakhouse

Where is Butcher Bros Steakhouse located?

Butcher Bros Steakhouse is located at 1410 Highland Avenue, Cheshire, CT 06410, USA.

What type of cuisine does Butcher Bros Steakhouse offer?

Butcher Bros Steakhouse offers a fine dining experience specializing in dry aged steaks and a variety of dishes prepared with fresh local ingredients.