Allred's

Reviews

• CM

  Charlotte M

  Jan 4, 2026
  5.0
  Allred’s never misses. From the moment we sat down at the bar, everything was flawless, warm hospitality, impeccable service, and every course was beautifully executed. A truly special dining experience and easily one of the best meals in Telluride. The crackling fire is a nice touch.
• DF

  Danis Fickewirth

  Jan 2, 2026
  1.0
  If you would like to actually be seated, choose another restaurant. I had a confirmed reservation, came a few minutes before 5PM, they acknowledged us, saw our name and checked us in. Then, people started showing up after us. The friends, the "hi, omg, how are yous". They sat three or four couples before us that showed up after us! The earliest dinner time is 5, so there is no way their reservations were earlier than ours. My pointing this out to the hostess was met with pretentiousness, attitude and saying that she does not see my reservation (she read my name from the computer some time before when I checked in, and I very conspicuously sat in a chair 5 feet from her the whole time after checking in). Unless you know them personally, I would honestly just go to another restaurant. People WITHOUT a reservation were seated before me. What appeared to be a group of 7 showed up after me and was seated before me. I sincerely regret giving them $850 in business two days ago. They grossly undercooked my wife's steak then, and the replacement took forever. I was done eating already by the time it came out. I decided to give them another chance, and now this. I chose to just leave and not spend my money there. I will never return. Do not go here! After I left tonight, I went to another restaurant instead in Telluride and had a very, very wonderful meal and amazing service. Disappointing. Dear management, if you care, look at the cameras, check out what happened to me at 5pm. The hostess I dealt with should be fired immediately at the very least!
• FT

  Fisher Trowbridge

  Jan 2, 2026
  5.0
  We really enjoyed our supper at Allreds. The staff was friendly and very helpful. The food was amazing and the dessert was just as good. The view is absolutely amazing and that much better if you can eat there during daylight. We will be back, one of the best in Telluride!
• AL

  Aly Lang

  Jan 1, 2026
  2.0
  VERY disappointed in overall experience. When you pay $250 a person (and that was just the food portion!!) With food/wine/cocktail- more like $400 PP), I expect flawless service. I understand that it was New Year's Eve but for this type of restaurant, they should not miss a beat. We had a food allergy and they served the soup WITH the allergy. Thank God my daughter saw it and alerted the server. It took long time to get the replacement. Food was very good but service was slow. One of the steaks was ordered medium and it came out very medium rare..didn't send it back because didn't know how long that one would have taken since the allergy redo took long, Asked if we wanted wine when we hadn't even been asked if we wanted a cocktail...and then had to ask for the cocktail menu as there wasn't one on the table. The worst part was going to the restroom to find NO toilet paper. How does that happen in a fine dining restaurant? She just said 'it's been a busy night'. When we left, no thank you...just a 'did you get your chocolates?' Training needs to improve, unreasonable hospitality was not there, except for the sommelier (she was lovely)...the restroom was dirty. We've eaten here a few times before and was really looking forward to our celebration but you fell short...I expect way better from Allreds.
• HH

  Helen

  Dec 27, 2025
  3.0
  Hair on plate. Crazy. Server was aloof and could care less. No personality. Actually ruined the experience for us The place is very pretty. The gentleman playing the organ had on a hoodie over his head. And a half eaten sandwich on top of the organ. Not worth the money. The food was OK - nothing special.

Frequently Asked Questions About Allred's