Customers frequently praised the freshness and deliciousness of the sandwiches, highlighting quality ingredients and good bread.
Service Consistency
While many reviews noted friendly and quick service, there were also mentions of inconsistent customer service experiences.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere was described as basic and lacking, with some customers noting cleanliness issues, especially in hot weather.
Pricing
Most customers found the prices reasonable for the quality of food, although some felt certain items were overpriced.
Order Accuracy
There were mixed reviews regarding order accuracy, with some customers experiencing issues with incorrect orders or missing items.
CM
Courtney Mackenzie
Nov 13, 2025
5.0
Mr. Lucky’s has become an absolute staple in my week! I love having such a great local spot right by my apartment. The food is always amazing — fresh ingredients, generous portions, and consistently delicious sandwiches that never miss. Especially love the bird and basil sandwich! The staff are incredibly friendly and welcoming, which makes every visit feel personal and enjoyable.
If you’re looking for a reliably great sandwich and a neighborhood vibe that feels like home, you can’t go wrong with Mr. Lucky’s. Highly recommend!
BM
Bruce Medina
Oct 20, 2025
5.0
Food is always fresh and delicious
LR
lenise rivera
Oct 20, 2025
2.0
I was excited to see that there was a location closer to me and had been wanting to take my husband, since he is a sandwich guy. I used to go the location off of 6th Ave. about 10yrs ago. Well, we were very disappointed!!! I got a half of the Colorado Club. My sandwich had only 1 slice per each of the 2 meats. There are just so light on the meat.
TC
tyler corley
Oct 2, 2025
5.0
They finally brought back all the good sandwiches to this location. Thank goodness. I was missing Mr. Lucky's from my life.