Disappointing Notary Service at Valley Bank – Longtime Customers Let Down
We have been loyal customers of Valley Bank for over 8 years, holding both savings and checking accounts. However, our recent experience at the 100 Park Ave branch on 02/24/2025 left us extremely disappointed.
We visited the branch to have a document notarized, something we have done at various banks without issue for the past 10 years. We had both the original and a copy of the document ready, but the notary at the branch refused to notarize it, stating that she only notarizes ‘bank-related documents.’ When we asked for clarification on what qualifies as a "bank-related document," she was unable to provide a clear answer.
To add to our frustration, my wife is a public notary and a former Valley Bank employee, so she is well aware of what can and cannot be notarized. Her professional knowledge made it clear that this refusal was unnecessary and unhelpful.
We have always trusted Valley Bank with our finances, but this lack of basic customer service and inability to assist loyal customers is unacceptable. If this is the level of service Valley Bank now provides, we would rather close our accounts and take our business to a bank that actually values and supports its customers.
If you’re considering this branch for notary services or general banking needs, be aware that you may not receive the help you expect or deserve.
CO
Carlos Obando
Sep 17, 2018
5.0
Nice people, friendly
CH
Collin Helmers
Mar 11, 2016
5.0
One of my favorite banks in NYC, Cathy and Victor are warm and extremely helpful, any time I've had a problem the whole staff works as a team to help me out. 10/10
What are the Valley Bank branch's regular operating hours?
Valley Bank is open Monday through Friday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM, and closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
Where is the Valley Bank branch located?
The branch is located at 100 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10017, USA.
How can I contact Valley Bank for inquiries?
You can reach Valley Bank by phone at +1 212-867-6242.
Does Valley Bank offer appointments outside of regular hours?
Yes, Valley Bank provides services by appointment only outside of their regular business hours.
Where can I find more information about Valley Bank Madison at Park online?
You can visit their website at https://www.valley.com/branches/madison-at-park for more details.
Are there mobile apps available for Valley Bank customers?
Yes, Valley Bank offers mobile apps available on both Android and iOS platforms for convenient banking.
Which nearby places might be convenient to visit before or after banking at Valley Bank?
Nearby places include Peking Park Restaurant for dining, Potbelly Sandwich Shop for quick meals, and MerciMedical Spa for relaxation.
Are there nearby financial services to assist with broader financial planning?
Yes, nearby financial services include TFX Capital Management and Pillars of Wall Street for financial advising and services.
What nearby professional services could complement a visit to Valley Bank?
Nearby professional services include Haque CPA for tax services, Hunt Executive Search Inc for employment agency needs, and Gioconda Law Group for legal services.
How can I stay updated about Valley Bank on social media?
You can follow Valley Bank on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/884729954923464 and on Instagram under the handle @valleybank.