Our First American Title office in Sheffield Village, OH provides comprehensive title insurance protection and professional escrow and settlement services for all types real estate transactions. By providing superior service and technology, First American delivers the industry's best customer experience. Contact our local First American Title team to experience the First American difference.
Staff was friendly and knowledgeable. Smooth transaction from start to finish
MW
Mary Frances Weir
Jun 24, 2025
5.0
5-Star service!! Melissa and Trish went above and beyond for an elderly couple who hadn't sold a home in decades. It was confusing and stressful--until these two gals made it easy and comfortable! Trish even went out to meet them early in the transaction, so they had a face with the name. Very grateful for these professional and caring people! Teamwork!!
SB
Stacey Burnett
Jun 10, 2025
5.0
Huge thanks to First American Title for going above and beyond to get our transaction to the finish line! Special shout out to Trish Milano and Kali Sobczak for their professionalism, dedication, and teamwork every step of the way. You made it happen—couldn’t have done it without you!
Stacey B
VG
Victor “Vito Gambino” Gambino
Oct 24, 2024
5.0
What a pleasant experience!
Since 1980, I have bought or sold 10 homes. By far (in fact, not even close) working with First American Title has been the best transfer ever.
From the first encounter with Allison to the closing/signing with Kali, we thoroughly were impressed with the handling of documents, exceptional communication, and personal approach.
We would definitely use them again and will share our experience within our circles of influence.
Thanks Allison and Kali!
SH
Sophia Hernandez-Ortiz
Jul 5, 2021
5.0
Yet another flawless transaction with First American Title. They are always due diligent, prompt with all communications, professional, friendly, and accommodating to my clients hectic schedules.
Frequently Asked Questions About First American Title Insurance Company
What services does First American Title Insurance Company provide?
They provide comprehensive title insurance coverage and professional escrow and closing services for real estate transactions including purchases, construction, refinances, and equity loans.
Where is First American Title Insurance Company located?
The office is located at 5505 Detroit Road, Suite D, Sheffield Village, OH 44054, USA.
What are the office hours for First American Title in Sheffield Village?
The office is open Monday through Friday from 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM. It is closed on Saturdays, Sundays, and certain holidays.
Is an appointment required to visit First American Title Insurance Company?
Yes, the office is open by appointment only until further notice, so please call ahead to schedule.
How can I contact First American Title Insurance Company?
You can contact them by phone at +1 440-934-4845 or by email at clwise@firstam.com.
Where can I find more information about First American Title in Sheffield Village?
Visit their website at https://local.firstam.com/oh/offices/elyria for more details and services.
Which nearby legal services are located close to First American Title?
Nearby legal services include The Law Offices Of R.J. Budway, O'toole, Mclaughlin, Dooley & Pecora Co., LPA, The Nicol Law Firm, and Ortner Law Group, which can assist with legal matters related to real estate and beyond.
What nearby medical facilities can customers visit around First American Title?
Customers can find several nearby medical services such as Medcare - Sheffield, Mercy Health - Heart and Vascular Institute, and Evergreen Pain Management and Rehabilitation Center if they need health-related services during their visit.
Are there any nearby insurance agencies near First American Title for additional coverage needs?
Yes, Daniela Christopher Agent at Mutual of Omaha, Danny Smith - Mutual of Omaha Advisor, and Andrew Betts: Allstate Insurance are nearby and can assist with insurance options.
What nearby real estate services complement First American Title Insurance Company?
Nearby real estate services include Alex Zelinko (real estate agent), The Sweda Group, and American Patriot Title Agency, which can be helpful for clients seeking additional real estate assistance.