Toyota DealerUsed Car DealerCar DealerAuto Repair ShopAuto Parts & AccessoriesOil Change Service StationTire ShopCar Leasing ServiceCar Finance and Loan Company
Search, Shop & Save at McCarthy Toyota of Sedalia. Searching for a quality new Toyota vehicle or used car for sale near Warrensburg? There’s no better hunting ground than our Sedalia car dealership. In addition to our expansive inventory of new, used and certified pre-owned vehicles for sale, we also offer affordable auto repairs and oil changes, discounts on OEM Toyota parts, and affordable car loan solutions for everyone. Enjoy the many perks of shopping at one of the best car dealers near you. Contact us to explore your options, including our free vehicle delivery service within 100 miles of Sedalia!
Many customers praised the friendly and professional service provided by sales staff, particularly highlighting individuals like Jamie Lemus, Dakota Shepard, and Kaleb McGinnis.
Sales Experience
Overall, customers reported a smooth and stress-free car buying experience, with several mentioning the low-pressure sales approach and attentiveness of the sales team.
Communication
Customers appreciated the clear and timely communication throughout the purchasing process, with many noting that they felt well-informed and supported.
Vehicle Quality Issues
Some customers expressed dissatisfaction with undisclosed vehicle issues and poor detailing upon delivery, indicating a need for improved quality control.
Service Department
While many praised the service department for its efficiency, there were complaints about pricing discrepancies and unresolved vehicle issues after service visits.
AA
AericcOnline
6 days ago
5.0
I was introduced to Geoff through mutual friends and when he heard about my situation, he helped me make an informed choice. Car's great, the rest of the staff were helpful and friendly, and I'll be back for sure for any of my auto needs.
CD
Cheryl DeLong
Nov 13, 2025
5.0
I was very impressed with McCarthy Toyota. We worked with JP Gowdy and he was terrific. He was very nice and helpful and found me the car that I wanted. JP was never pushy and worked with me so I could get a good deal on my car. Everyone at the dealership was great - Richard showed me so much about my car and Larry was great with the financing. I highly recommend McCarthy Toyota in Sedalia.
MM
Michelle Martinson
Nov 13, 2025
5.0
What an amazing car purchasing experience! Caleb and Cowboy Dan are absolutely fantastic to work with! I gave them my must have check list and they delivered quickly! Thank you!
JB
Jackie Burns
Nov 3, 2025
5.0
Although I live in the KC area, I made the trip to Sedalia to look at a car advertised on McCarthy Toyota's lot. There I met Jaime Lemus. After the test drive (which I requested to go on twice), Jaime spoke with me about my thoughts on the car, and we discussed numbers. I knew I was not buying a car that day and asked for his card. Throughout the next week as I compared the McCarthy car against another car in KC, Jaime kept in touch. We had a good rapport, and he answered all my (what I'm sure seemed like endless) questions with much patience. However, it wasn't in the cards, as the car sold before I made a decision.
Although I didn't buy a car from him, Jaime still followed up with an email, thanking me. I received no such call from the salesman from whom I actually did buy a car from. I really wish I could have bought from Jaime. If you can, I highly recommend you do. I hear the service department is top notch too.
MP
Matthew Prindle
Oct 30, 2025
5.0
Great team to work with! Geoff helped me understand available options, time frame for new vehicles, he was patient and made the overall process smooth even though buying a vehicle can be lengthy. He, along with his management team, was able to answer every question or clarification I had. He wasn't pushy nor a stickler when it came down to the numbers but rather advocated for my own personal financial goals concerning this purchase. Brian was also very friendly and welcoming as we were finalizing the deal helping me understand the Toyota Care packages, what to have ready to report to my own insurance, etc. I highly recommend McCarthy Toyota if you're at this stage looking for a new or used vehicle.